Business tips & ideas

How to Get Product Reviews the Right Way (Before the Holidays)

Rabfy Team  ·  8 min read

How to Get Product Reviews the Right Way (Before the Holidays)

Reviews sell gifts. A shopper buying a necklace for their mom cannot touch it, so they look for proof that it arrives on time, looks like the photos and makes people happy. If you are wondering how to get product reviews before the holiday rush, the answer is not a trick. It is a simple system: ask every buyer, at the right time, in the right way, and follow the rules.

This guide covers when to ask, what to say, the FTC's rule on fake reviews, the review rules on Etsy and Amazon, and how to answer negative reviews. It is not legal advice, so check the official pages for your channels before you change anything.

Key takeaways

  • Ask every buyer the same way. Asking only happy customers could violate the FTC Act.

  • Ask a few days after delivery, not at checkout.

  • Never buy, fake or filter reviews. Since Oct 21, 2024, the FTC can seek civil penalties for fake reviews.

  • Marketplaces are stricter: Amazon bans any reward for a review, and Etsy bans shilling.

  • Reply to every review, especially the negative ones. Future buyers are reading.

Why reviews matter more in November and December

Gift buyers take more risk than people buying for themselves. If the product disappoints, it is their gift that fails. Reviews reduce that risk. They show that the piece looks like the photos, that the message card arrived in good condition and that the order came on time.

Reviews also matter on marketplaces. On Etsy and Amazon, star ratings appear next to listings in search results, so they affect whether shoppers click at all.

Timing is tight. Reviews arrive after delivery, so the reviews you ask for this week will show up during the busiest weeks of December. If you start today, you still have time.

The rules: what the FTC fake reviews rule bans

In August 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced a final rule that bans fake reviews and testimonials. The FTC fake reviews rule took effect on October 21, 2024, and it lets the FTC seek civil penalties against businesses that knowingly break it. It covers six practices:

Six practices banned by the FTC 2024 rule on fake reviews: fake reviews, reviews paid for a set sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, fake review websites, review suppression and fake social media followers or views.
Six practices banned by the FTC 2024 rule on fake reviews: fake reviews, reviews paid for a set sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, fake review websites, review suppression and fake social media followers or views.

Two more points from the FTC's own questions-and-answers page matter for small sellers. First, you can ask customers for reviews in general, but asking only the customers you think are happy could violate the FTC Act. Second, the rule allows incentives that do not depend on a positive or negative review, but hiding those incentives can also break the FTC Act, so they must be clearly disclosed.

Review rules on Etsy and Amazon

Marketplaces add their own rules on top of the law, and they are often stricter. Here is a quick summary at the time of writing. Always confirm on each platform's official policy pages.

Table of review rules by channel: the FTC, Etsy, Amazon and your own store all allow honest, neutral review requests, but ban fake, paid-for-praise or filtered reviews.
Table of review rules by channel: the FTC, Etsy, Amazon and your own store all allow honest, neutral review requests, but ban fake, paid-for-praise or filtered reviews.

Etsy reviews

On Etsy, buyers have 100 days to review an order, starting from the delivery date or estimated delivery date. Etsy's shilling policy bans having friends or family buy an item to leave a biased review, and bans giving free or discounted items, cash or other rewards to get biased positive reviews. You can reply to Etsy reviews, and Etsy's Seller Policy says reviews and responses must not undermine the review system.

Amazon reviews

Amazon's customer review policies say sellers must not offer a financial reward, discount, free product or other compensation in exchange for a review. Sellers also must not ask only for positive reviews, or ask a customer to change or remove a review. Neutral requests are allowed, and Seller Central has a Request a Review button that sends a standard request from Amazon during a set window after delivery.

The safest rule for every marketplace: do not offer any reward for a review, even where the FTC would allow a neutral incentive. Marketplace rules can be stricter than the law, and breaking them can put your seller account at risk.

When to ask for a review

Timing is the biggest thing you control. Ask too early and the buyer has not received the gift yet. Ask too late and they have forgotten about it.

Timeline for review requests: thank the buyer on order day, share tracking when the order ships, ask for a review 3–5 days after delivery, and send at most one gentle reminder about a week later.
Timeline for review requests: thank the buyer on order day, share tracking when the order ships, ask for a review 3–5 days after delivery, and send at most one gentle reminder about a week later.

For gifts, remember that the buyer may not have given the gift yet. A line such as "If you have already given the gift, we would love to hear how it was received" works well. For Christmas orders, a review request in early January can work better than one in mid-December.

What to say: a review request template

Keep it short, personal and neutral. Ask for honest feedback, not five stars. Here is a simple ask for reviews email you can adapt. It follows the same style as our customer service templates.

Notice what the template does not do. It does not ask for five stars. It does not offer a discount. It does not say "if you loved it". Those small choices keep you inside the rules.

  • Make it one tap: link directly to the review page, not to your homepage.
  • Invite photos: photos of the gift help future buyers, but keep them optional.
  • Send it to everyone: use the same automatic flow for every order, so you never filter by who seems happy.
Comparison of risky and right review requests: ask every buyer with neutral wording, offer no reward on marketplaces, ask after delivery, and reply calmly to bad reviews instead of hiding them.
Comparison of risky and right review requests: ask every buyer with neutral wording, offer no reward on marketplaces, ask after delivery, and reply calmly to bad reviews instead of hiding them.

How to answer negative reviews

Every shop gets a bad review eventually. Future buyers often read your reply more closely than the review itself. A calm, helpful reply shows that you take care of problems.

  1. 1
    Reply within a day or two, and thank the buyer for the feedback.
  2. 2
    Say sorry for the problem without arguing or blaming the carrier.
  3. 3
    Offer a fix in private messages, such as a replacement, a refund or a correction, based on your policy.
  4. 4
    Never offer money or a refund in exchange for changing or removing a review. Amazon's policies ban it, and it damages trust everywhere.

Many negative reviews on personalized products come from a wrong name or a missing card. Clear personalization fields, a copy-and-paste process and a clear return policy for personalized products prevent most of them.

Build a review system that runs itself

You do not need to remember to ask. Set it up once, per channel:

  • Shopify: use a reviews app that sends an automatic request after delivery and shows all reviews on the product page, not only the good ones.
  • Etsy: Etsy runs its own review system, so check what buyers already receive before you add messages, and keep any message neutral.
  • Amazon: use the Request a Review button or Amazon-approved tools, and follow Amazon's messaging rules.

If you are just starting out, the reviews from your first orders matter most. Our guide to getting your first 10 sales on Shopify shows how to win those first customers, and our print-on-demand jewelry guide helps you choose products people are happy to review.

Frequently asked questions

How do I get product reviews without breaking the rules?

Ask every buyer the same neutral question a few days after delivery, link directly to the review page, and never offer a reward for a positive review. On marketplaces, follow their own rules, which are often stricter.

Can I offer a discount in exchange for a review?

Under the FTC rule, an incentive must not depend on a positive or negative review and should be clearly disclosed. But Amazon bans any compensation for reviews, and Etsy bans rewards for biased positive reviews. The safest choice is no reward at all.

Is it legal to ask only happy customers for reviews?

The FTC says asking only customers you think are happy could violate the FTC Act. Send the same request to every buyer.

When is the best time to ask for a review?

About 3–5 days after delivery. For gifts, the buyer may need more time to give the gift, so one gentle reminder about a week later can help, where your channel allows it.

What is the FTC fake reviews rule?

It is a final rule announced in August 2024 that took effect on October 21, 2024. It bans fake reviews, reviews paid for a set sentiment, undisclosed insider reviews, fake review sites, review suppression and fake social media indicators, and it allows civil penalties.

Earn reviews with orders that arrive right

Rabfy produces, quality-checks and ships your orders with tracking, so more buyers have something good to say. Start free, with no subscription, and pay only when you get an order.

Start selling free